Publication Ethics
Publication Ethics and Malpractice Statement
AKSELERASI : Jurnal Pendidikan Guru MI is committed to maintaining integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability throughout the publication process. Its ethical policies are informed by the guidance and Core Practices of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) , together with applicable Indonesian requirements for scientific publication and journal accreditation.
These responsibilities apply to authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher. Publication decisions must reflect scholarly merit, methodological or conceptual rigor, ethical integrity, and relevance to Madrasah Ibtidaiyah and primary school teacher education.
The Faculty of Tarbiyah and Teacher Training, Universitas Islam Negeri Kiai Haji Achmad Siddiq Jember, as the publisher, supports editorial independence and the responsible management of the journal. Institutional interests, advertising, sponsorship, payments, or other financial considerations must not determine editorial decisions.
Responsibilities of Editors
Editorial decisions. Editors assess submissions for relevance, originality, scholarly quality, clarity, and ethical compliance. Manuscripts that pass initial assessment undergo double-blind peer review by at least two independent reviewers. The final decision rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor, who considers the reviewers’ reports and the authors’ responses.
Fair and impartial assessment. Manuscripts are evaluated on their academic merits without discrimination based on authors’ gender, ethnicity, nationality, religion, disability, political beliefs, institutional affiliation, or academic status. Editors must not require authors to adopt a particular position unrelated to the scholarly evaluation of their work.
Confidentiality. Information about submissions may be shared only with individuals who need it for legitimate editorial, review, production, or ethics-related purposes. Access must be limited to what is necessary. Reviewer identities must not be disclosed to authors without appropriate authorization.
Conflicts of interest. Editors must disclose relevant competing interests and withdraw from handling affected submissions. Papers submitted by editors, editorial board members, or individuals with close personal or professional relationships to an editor must be handled independently by an editor without a relevant conflict.
Responsible use of unpublished information. Editors must not use unpublished findings, data, or ideas obtained through editorial work for personal advantage or their own research without the authors’ express permission.
Protection of the scholarly record. Editors must consider credible ethical concerns before and after publication, seek relevant evidence and explanations, and arrange corrections, expressions of concern, or retractions when warranted.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Expertise and timeliness. Reviewers should accept assignments only when they have suitable expertise and can complete the review within the agreed period. They must promptly notify the editor if they cannot complete an assessment or require additional time.
Objective and constructive assessment. Reviews must evaluate the manuscript rather than the authors. Comments should be clear, respectful, supported by reasons, and directed toward assessing or improving the work. Personal criticism and discriminatory or abusive language are unacceptable.
Confidentiality. Manuscripts and review materials are confidential. Reviewers must not share them, involve another person in preparing a review, or contact authors about the submission without editorial permission. Unpublished information must not be used for personal advantage.
Competing interests. Reviewers must disclose relationships or interests that could compromise an impartial assessment, including close collaboration, institutional connections, personal relationships, or financial interests. If a reviewer recognizes an author during double-blind review, the editor must be informed so that continued participation can be assessed.
Sources and potential misconduct. Reviewers should identify substantive problems with attribution, unsupported claims, suspected plagiarism, redundant publication, or other ethical concerns and report them confidentially to the editor. Suggested citations must have a clear scholarly justification and must not be used to inflate citation counts.
Use of artificial intelligence. Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or review materials to public generative AI services. They remain personally responsible for their assessments and must not delegate editorial judgment to an automated system.
Responsibilities of Authors
Accurate and transparent reporting. Authors must present an accurate account of their work, explain their methods or analytical approach, and distinguish evidence from interpretation. Conclusions must be supported by the reported findings. Relevant limitations must be acknowledged. Fabrication, falsification, and misleading manipulation of data, quotations, images, or results are unacceptable.
Originality and acknowledgment. Authors must submit original work and appropriately acknowledge the ideas, words, data, instruments, and other materials of others. Verbatim passages must be clearly identified and cited. Reuse of authors’ own published material must be disclosed and appropriately referenced. Permission must be obtained for material when required by its rights holder or license.
Exclusive submission and overlapping publication. A manuscript must not be submitted to another journal while it is under consideration by AKSELERASI. Authors must disclose related publications, preprints, conference papers, theses, or other versions and explain any substantive overlap. Unjustified duplication or fragmentation of substantially the same research is unacceptable.
Authorship and contributorship. All listed authors must have made a substantial intellectual contribution, participated in drafting or critically revising the manuscript, approved the submitted version, and agreed to be accountable for their contributions and to help resolve concerns about the work. Individuals who do not meet these criteria should be acknowledged, with their permission. Gift, guest, and ghost authorship are unacceptable.
Corresponding author responsibilities. The corresponding author must ensure that the author list and order have been agreed upon, that all authors approve submission and subsequent revisions, and that editorial communications are shared with co-authors. Proposed authorship changes must be explained to the editor and supported by the agreement of all affected individuals.
Research involving human participants. Authors must describe the ethical safeguards appropriate to their study, including ethics approval or an applicable exemption where required, informed consent, confidentiality, and protection from harm. Permission from a school or institution does not replace participant consent. Research involving children must address permission from parents or legal guardians and age-appropriate assent, unless an authorized ethics review permits an alternative procedure.
Privacy and consent for publication. Identifiable photographs, personal information, interview quotations, and other sensitive materials must be handled responsibly. Authors must obtain consent for publication when identification is possible and consent is required. Anonymization must protect participants without distorting the meaning of the evidence.
Data integrity and availability. Authors should retain the research records needed to substantiate their findings and respond to reasonable editorial requests for verification. Data sharing must respect consent, confidentiality, applicable requirements, and legitimate restrictions. Authors should explain relevant restrictions rather than disclose protected participant information.
Funding and competing interests. Authors must disclose financial and non-financial interests that could reasonably be perceived to influence the work. Funding sources and the funder’s role, if any, in study design, data collection, analysis, writing, or submission must be stated. Where no relevant competing interests exist, authors should explicitly declare this.
Responsible use of generative AI. AI tools cannot be listed as authors. Authors remain responsible for the accuracy, originality, references, and integrity of all submitted content. Substantive AI assistance in generating text, analyzing data, or creating research materials must be transparently described. AI use must not fabricate evidence, citations, or research activities, or compromise confidential information.
Errors discovered after publication. Authors who identify a significant error must promptly notify the editorial office and cooperate in assessing its implications. Authors must also respond to substantiated concerns raised by others and assist with appropriate correction or retraction when necessary.
Responsibilities of the Publisher
The publisher supports independent editorial decisions, confidential handling of submissions, transparent publication policies, and the preservation of the scholarly record. It must not pressure editors to accept or reject manuscripts for commercial, personal, or institutional advantage.
Where ethical concerns arise, the publisher supports the editorial team in seeking explanations, consulting relevant institutions or specialists when necessary, and implementing justified editorial notices. Publication charges, where applicable, must not determine the outcome of an ethics investigation or publication decision.
Allegations, Complaints, and Appeals
Suspected misconduct or concerns about editorial conduct should be submitted to the editorial office through the contact details published on the journal website. Reports should identify the manuscript or article and provide a clear explanation and supporting evidence. Concerns are assessed on their merits, including those reported anonymously when sufficient evidence is provided.
The journal will assess credible concerns impartially, seek explanations from the relevant parties, and provide a reasonable opportunity to respond. Confidentiality will be maintained as far as practicable. Where a formal investigation is needed, the journal may refer the matter to the relevant institution or responsible body; editorial action may proceed when sufficient evidence is available.
Actions may include requests for clarification or revision, rejection, a published correction, an expression of concern, or retraction, depending on the evidence and its implications for the reliability of the work. Retraction serves to correct the scholarly record rather than punish individuals. Published notices should explain the reasons for the action and be linked to the affected article.
Authors may appeal an editorial decision by providing a reasoned explanation and relevant evidence. Appeals and complaints concerning an editor must be considered by another authorized editor or publisher representative without a relevant conflict of interest. An appeal does not guarantee a different decision.